Books Like Her Soul to Take
If you finished Her Soul to Take and want more demons, possessive hero, villain gets the girl, start here. Each pick shares at least two tropes with it, and we've rated every one for spice and darkness so you know what you're getting into.
For reference, Her Soul to Take is:
Last updated
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend. How we make money.
The picks
-
1. Haunting Adeline
Shares: possessive hero, morally gray, villain gets the girl
The book that made dark romance go viral. A stalker, a gothic manor and a lot that's legitimately disturbing. Read every warning before you start. It earns its reputation.
- Stalker Romance
- Possessive Hero
- Morally Gray
- Villain Gets the Girl
Content warnings
Stalking, Dubious or non-consent, Sexual assault, Human trafficking, Murder, Gore
-
2. Hooked
Shares: villain gets the girl, morally gray
Peter Pan, except Hook runs a criminal empire and Wendy is the daughter of the man he wants dead. Each book in the series is a different villain. Great entry point if you want dark romance that isn't relentless.
- Fairy Tale Retellings
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Mafia
- Revenge
Content warnings
Murder, Graphic violence, Death of a loved one
-
3. Blood of My Monster
Shares: possessive hero, morally gray
Sasha hides as a man to work security for a Bratva boss, and Kirill figures out a lot faster than she'd like. Classic Rina Kent: violent, obsessive and very spicy. The trilogy has to be read in order.
- Mafia
- Captor and Captive
- Possessive Hero
- Morally Gray
Content warnings
Graphic violence, Murder, Torture, Dubious or non-consent
-
4. Deviant
Shares: morally gray, possessive hero
Dr. Sloane Romera goes looking for her missing best friend and ends up needing Zeth Mayfair, a Seattle criminal with very particular tastes. Readers who came from Quicksilver are often shocked by how dark it is. Collected now as Blood & Roses Volume 1.
- Morally Gray
- Possessive Hero
- Forbidden Love
Content warnings
Human trafficking, Graphic violence, Murder, Physical or emotional abuse, Drug or alcohol abuse
-
5. Buttons and Lace
Shares: villain gets the girl, possessive hero
She owes Crow Barsetti, so he decides he owns her. The Barsetti books get softer later, but this opener is very dark and readers single it out for its rape content. Not a starter book.
- Captor and Captive
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Possessive Hero
- Mafia
Content warnings
Sexual assault, Kidnapping, Physical or emotional abuse, Graphic violence
-
6. Crow
Shares: morally gray, possessive hero
Crow is an Irish mob enforcer in Boston, and Mack is a woman with no options left who ends up owing him. Gritty and sad in places, with a hero who's a killer and doesn't apologize. Heavy warnings, including an on-page assault.
- Mafia
- Morally Gray
- Possessive Hero
- Touch Her and Die
Content warnings
Human trafficking, Sexual assault, Murder, Death of a loved one
-
7. Deliver
Shares: villain gets the girl, morally gray
Liv Reed is taken and handed to Van Quiso, whose job is training captives to be sold. As dark as captor romance gets, with a slow, strange turn toward something like love. For seasoned readers only.
- Captor and Captive
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Morally Gray
Content warnings
Human trafficking, Sexual assault, Dubious or non-consent, Kidnapping, Torture
-
8. Den of Vipers
Shares: villain gets the girl, possessive hero
Kidnapped by four men to settle her father's debt, and she ends up falling for all of them. Violent and over the top, and it knows exactly what it is.
- Why Choose
- Captor and Captive
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Possessive Hero
Content warnings
Kidnapping, Dubious or non-consent, Torture, Gore, Murder
-
9. Does It Hurt?
Shares: morally gray, possessive hero
Sawyer is a con artist on the run, and Enzo Vitale is the man she tries to steal from. Then things go very wrong for both of them. Less stalker than Haunting Adeline, but the backstories are brutal, so read the warning list first.
- Captor and Captive
- Enemies to Lovers
- Morally Gray
- Possessive Hero
Content warnings
Harm to children, Sexual assault, Kidnapping, Torture, Murder
-
10. Lights Out
Shares: possessive hero, morally gray
Josie has a masked-stalker fantasy, and a hacker named Aiden makes it real. The twist is that she's into it and he keeps checking in. Funny, filthy, and a soft landing if Haunting Adeline sounds like too much.
- Stalker Romance
- Possessive Hero
- Morally Gray
- Touch Her and Die
Content warnings
Stalking, Physical or emotional abuse, Death of a loved one, Graphic violence
-
11. Promises and Pomegranates
Shares: possessive hero, morally gray
A modern Hades and Persephone where Hades is a hitman named Kal and Persephone is Elena Rossi, a mafia daughter who's tired of being kept. The prose is moodier than most mafia books. Each sequel follows a new couple.
- Gods and Mythology
- Mafia
- Possessive Hero
- Morally Gray
Content warnings
Graphic violence, Murder, Physical or emotional abuse
-
12. Ruthless Creatures
Shares: possessive hero, morally gray
Natalie's fiancé vanished, and the Russian mobster who shows up looking for him decides he wants her instead. Kage is gruff, devoted and frankly funny. Lighter on darkness than the cover suggests and a lot heavier on spice.
- Mafia
- Possessive Hero
- Touch Her and Die
- Morally Gray
Content warnings
Graphic violence, Murder
-
13. Tears of Tess
Shares: villain gets the girl, possessive hero
Tess is abducted on vacation with her boyfriend and sold to a Frenchman known only as Q. One of the early books that defined captive dark romance, and it doesn't soften anything. Check the author's warnings first.
- Captor and Captive
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Possessive Hero
Content warnings
Human trafficking, Kidnapping, Sexual assault, Torture, Physical or emotional abuse
-
14. The Silver Swan
Shares: possessive hero, morally gray
Madison Montgomery transfers to Riverside and lands in the middle of a secret club of ten guys run by Bishop Hayes. The plot is chaotic and twisty to the point of confusion, and people love it for exactly that. One reader noted the front-matter warnings don't cover everything.
- Dark Academia
- Enemies to Lovers
- Possessive Hero
- Morally Gray
Content warnings
Suicide or suicidal thoughts, Harm to children, Graphic violence
-
15. Twist Me
Shares: possessive hero, villain gets the girl
Julian kidnaps eighteen-year-old Nora and keeps her on a private island. That's the setup, and the book is honest that he is not a good man. Pure captor fantasy, often recommended alongside Captive in the Dark.
- Captor and Captive
- Possessive Hero
- Villain Gets the Girl
Content warnings
Kidnapping, Dubious or non-consent, Sexual assault, Graphic violence
Read more than just Her Soul to Take? Tap everything you've loved and we'll build a reading list around all of it, not just this one book.