One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig book cover

Books Like One Dark Window

If you finished One Dark Window and want more curses, morally gray, forbidden love, start here. Each pick shares at least two tropes with it, and we've rated every one for spice and darkness so you know what you're getting into.

For reference, One Dark Window is:

Spice 1/5 Darkness 3/5

Last updated

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend. How we make money.

The picks

  1. 1. House of Hollow

    Krystal Sutherland · standalone

    Spice 0/5 Darkness 4/5

    Shares: curses

    Three sisters vanished as kids and came back with black eyes and no memories. Now the oldest is missing again. Gross, glittery body horror with a fae core. YA but not soft.

    • Fae
    • Curses
    • Fairy Tale Retellings
    Content warnings

    Gore, Kidnapping, Murder, Harm to children

  2. 2. Darkfever

    Karen Marie Moning · Fever #1

    Spice 1/5 Darkness 3/5

    Shares: morally gray, slow burn

    Mac goes to Dublin to find out who killed her sister and finds out she can see the fae. They're nothing like the stories. The romance with Barrons takes several books and gets very dark. This was dark fae before dark fae was a shelf.

    • Fae
    • Morally Gray
    • Slow Burn
    • Possessive Hero
    Content warnings

    Murder, Graphic violence, Death of a loved one

  3. 3. For the Wolf

    Hannah Whitten · The Wilderwood #1 · complete series

    Spice 1/5 Darkness 3/5

    Shares: curses, slow burn

    Red, the queen's second daughter, is sent into the Wilderwood as a sacrifice to the Wolf and finds a grumpy Warden named Eammon bleeding into the trees to keep them back. Red Riding Hood meets Beauty and the Beast with forest horror. Slow and tender.

    • Fairy Tale Retellings
    • Curses
    • Forced Proximity
    • Slow Burn
    Content warnings

    Gore, Graphic violence

  4. 4. House of Salt and Sorrows

    Erin A. Craig · standalone

    Spice 0/5 Darkness 3/5

    Shares: curses, forbidden love

    Annaleigh lives in a seaside manor with her sisters, four of whom have already died, and the rest keep sneaking off to enchanted balls every night. The Twelve Dancing Princesses as gothic horror. The romance is light. The creep factor isn't.

    • Fairy Tale Retellings
    • Curses
    • Forbidden Love
    Content warnings

    Death of a loved one, Murder, Gore

  5. 5. The Stolen Heir

    Holly Black · The Stolen Heir #1 · complete series

    Spice 0/5 Darkness 3/5

    Shares: morally gray, forbidden love

    Suren, the runaway child queen of the Court of Teeth, has been living feral in the New England woods when Prince Oak turns up asking for help on a quest. Set after The Folk of the Air, sadder than Jude's books, and Oak is far more slippery than he looks.

    • Fae
    • Court Intrigue
    • Morally Gray
    • Forbidden Love
    Content warnings

    Physical or emotional abuse, Graphic violence, Murder

  6. 6. These Violent Delights

    Chloe Gong · These Violent Delights #1 · complete series

    Spice 0/5 Darkness 3/5

    Shares: forbidden love, morally gray

    Romeo and Juliet in 1926 Shanghai. Juliette is heir to the Scarlet Gang, Roma is heir to the rival White Flowers, and a contagion is making people tear their own throats out. Atmospheric and gory, with a monster in the Huangpu River.

    • Enemies to Lovers
    • Forbidden Love
    • Morally Gray
    Content warnings

    Gore, Graphic violence, Murder, Suicide or suicidal thoughts

  7. 7. Daughter of No Worlds

    Carissa Broadbent · War of Lost Hearts #1 · complete series

    Spice 3/5 Darkness 3/5

    Shares: slow burn, forbidden love

    A former slave with a talent for magic gets recruited into an order of warriors. Broadbent before Nyaxia, and the slow burn here is properly slow.

    • Slow Burn
    • Forbidden Love
    • Found Family
    • Deadly Trials
    Content warnings

    Physical or emotional abuse, Graphic violence, War

  8. 8. Gild

    Raven Kennedy · The Plated Prisoner #1 · complete series

    Spice 2/5 Darkness 4/5

    Shares: slow burn, morally gray

    Auren is King Midas's gilded favorite, living in an actual birdcage and calling it love. Then raiders grab her on the road and a fae commander named Rip becomes her problem. Gild is slow and mostly setup. Glint is where the series takes off.

    • Captor and Captive
    • Fae
    • Slow Burn
    • Morally Gray
    Content warnings

    Sexual assault, Human trafficking, Physical or emotional abuse, Kidnapping, Murder

  9. 9. Gods of Jade and Shadow

    Silvia Moreno-Garcia · standalone

    Spice 0/5 Darkness 2/5

    Shares: forbidden love, slow burn

    Casiopea scrubs floors for her awful grandfather in 1920s Mexico until she opens an old chest and frees Hun-Kamé, the Maya god of death. They road-trip to get his throne back. More fable than romance, with a bittersweet ending.

    • Gods and Mythology
    • Forbidden Love
    • Slow Burn
    • Forced Proximity
    Content warnings

    Physical or emotional abuse, Graphic violence

  10. 10. House of Earth and Blood

    Sarah J. Maas · Crescent City #1

    Spice 3/5 Darkness 3/5

    Shares: morally gray, slow burn

    Urban fantasy Maas: phones, clubs, angels and a half-fae party girl hunting whoever killed her best friend. The first 200 pages are a slog and the last 200 are a sprint.

    • Fae
    • Demons
    • Morally Gray
    • Slow Burn
    Content warnings

    Graphic violence, Gore, Murder, Drug or alcohol abuse, Death of a loved one

  11. 11. Once Upon a Broken Heart

    Stephanie Garber · Once Upon a Broken Heart #1 · complete series

    Spice 1/5 Darkness 2/5

    Shares: curses, morally gray, forbidden love

    Evangeline Fox makes a deal with Jacks, the Prince of Hearts, to stop the wedding of the boy she loves. The price is three kisses, collected whenever he likes. Sugary fairy-tale prose with a hero who is absolutely not a hero.

    • Deals and Bargains
    • Curses
    • Morally Gray
    • Forbidden Love
    Content warnings

    Murder, Death of a loved one

  12. 12. The Darkest Part of the Forest

    Holly Black · standalone

    Spice 0/5 Darkness 2/5

    Shares: curses, forbidden love

    In Fairfold, tourists come to gawk at a horned boy asleep in a glass coffin in the woods. Then Hazel finds the coffin smashed and empty. Two romances, one of them queer, and a brother-sister story that hits just as hard.

    • Fae
    • Curses
    • Found Family
    • Forbidden Love
    Content warnings

    Graphic violence, Physical or emotional abuse

  13. 13. The Wretched Divine

    Adalyn Grace · The Wretched Divine #1

    Spice 2/5 Darkness 4/5

    Shares: forbidden love, morally gray

    Grace's adult debut: a knight bonded to an angel has to team up with a demon to find a cure. Way darker than Belladonna and a bit overstuffed, but the emotional core is the most complicated thing she's written.

    • Demons
    • Forbidden Love
    • Enemies to Lovers
    • Morally Gray
    Content warnings

    Graphic violence, Death of a loved one

  14. 14. Wicked Saints

    Emily A. Duncan · Something Dark and Holy #1 · complete series

    Spice 0/5 Darkness 4/5

    Shares: forbidden love, morally gray

    A girl who talks to gods, a blood mage prince and a war that never ends. Moody and extremely Slavic. The romance is with someone who's very clearly a villain.

    • Gods and Mythology
    • Villain Gets the Girl
    • Forbidden Love
    • Morally Gray
    Content warnings

    Self-harm, Gore, War, Torture

  15. 15. A Cursed Kiss

    Jenny Hickman · Myths of Airren #1 · complete series

    Spice 2/5 Darkness 2/5

    Shares: curses, morally gray, forbidden love

    Keelynn's sister died from a Gancanagh's cursed kiss, so she teams up with a witch and the half-fae Tadhg to bring her back. Irish folklore all the way down. There's a lot of miscommunication, but Tadhg carries it.

    • Fae
    • Curses
    • Enemies to Lovers
    • Morally Gray
    Content warnings

    Death of a loved one, Murder, Graphic violence

Read more than just One Dark Window? Tap everything you've loved and we'll build a reading list around all of it, not just this one book.