Books Like A Soul to Keep
If you finished A Soul to Keep and want more captor and captive, forced proximity, possessive hero, start here. Each pick shares at least two tropes with it, and we've rated every one for spice and darkness so you know what you're getting into.
For reference, A Soul to Keep is:
Last updated
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend. How we make money.
The picks
-
1. The Professional
Shares: possessive hero, captor and captive
Grad student Natalie Porter wants answers about her birth family, and enforcer Aleksandr Sevastyan whisks her off to Russia. Old-school erotic Bratva romance, a little dated but still a cult favorite.
- Mafia
- Possessive Hero
- Captor and Captive
- Stalker Romance
Content warnings
Stalking, Kidnapping, Murder, Torture
-
2. Blood of My Monster
Shares: captor and captive, possessive hero
Sasha hides as a man to work security for a Bratva boss, and Kirill figures out a lot faster than she'd like. Classic Rina Kent: violent, obsessive and very spicy. The trilogy has to be read in order.
- Mafia
- Captor and Captive
- Possessive Hero
- Morally Gray
Content warnings
Graphic violence, Murder, Torture, Dubious or non-consent
-
3. Credence
Shares: forced proximity, possessive hero
After her parents die, Tiernan is sent to live in a remote mountain house with her stepuncle Jake and his two sons. The taboo is the whole point. Atmospheric snowed-in setting, but it's one of Douglas's most divisive books for a reason.
- Forbidden Love
- Why Choose
- Forced Proximity
- Possessive Hero
Content warnings
Dubious or non-consent, Sexual assault, Physical or emotional abuse, Suicide or suicidal thoughts
-
4. Buttons and Lace
Shares: captor and captive, possessive hero
She owes Crow Barsetti, so he decides he owns her. The Barsetti books get softer later, but this opener is very dark and readers single it out for its rape content. Not a starter book.
- Captor and Captive
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Possessive Hero
- Mafia
Content warnings
Sexual assault, Kidnapping, Physical or emotional abuse, Graphic violence
-
5. Den of Vipers
Shares: captor and captive, possessive hero
Kidnapped by four men to settle her father's debt, and she ends up falling for all of them. Violent and over the top, and it knows exactly what it is.
- Why Choose
- Captor and Captive
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Possessive Hero
Content warnings
Kidnapping, Dubious or non-consent, Torture, Gore, Murder
-
6. Does It Hurt?
Shares: captor and captive, possessive hero
Sawyer is a con artist on the run, and Enzo Vitale is the man she tries to steal from. Then things go very wrong for both of them. Less stalker than Haunting Adeline, but the backstories are brutal, so read the warning list first.
- Captor and Captive
- Enemies to Lovers
- Morally Gray
- Possessive Hero
Content warnings
Harm to children, Sexual assault, Kidnapping, Torture, Murder
-
7. Tears of Tess
Shares: captor and captive, possessive hero
Tess is abducted on vacation with her boyfriend and sold to a Frenchman known only as Q. One of the early books that defined captive dark romance, and it doesn't soften anything. Check the author's warnings first.
- Captor and Captive
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Possessive Hero
Content warnings
Human trafficking, Kidnapping, Sexual assault, Torture, Physical or emotional abuse
-
8. Twist Me
Shares: captor and captive, possessive hero
Julian kidnaps eighteen-year-old Nora and keeps her on a private island. That's the setup, and the book is honest that he is not a good man. Pure captor fantasy, often recommended alongside Captive in the Dark.
- Captor and Captive
- Possessive Hero
- Villain Gets the Girl
Content warnings
Kidnapping, Dubious or non-consent, Sexual assault, Graphic violence
-
9. Comfort Food
Shares: captor and captive, possessive hero
Often called one of the original modern dark romances. A woman is taken and kept by a man who wants her to need him, and the book lives inside her conditioning. Short, quiet and deeply unsettling.
- Captor and Captive
- Villain Gets the Girl
- Possessive Hero
Content warnings
Kidnapping, Physical or emotional abuse, Dubious or non-consent
-
10. Pestilence
Shares: captor and captive, forced proximity
The apocalypse is here, and firefighter Sara Burns shoots the first Horseman with an arrow. He doesn't stay dead, and now she's his captive on a road trip of plague. Grim premise, banter-heavy delivery. War, the second book, is many readers' favorite.
- Enemies to Lovers
- Captor and Captive
- Gods and Mythology
- Forced Proximity
Content warnings
Torture, Kidnapping, Murder, Graphic violence
Read more than just A Soul to Keep? Tap everything you've loved and we'll build a reading list around all of it, not just this one book.